What's up with AAAI reviewers and organizers? [D]

A reviewer for AAAI expressed frustration regarding the paper review process, particularly concerning a paper on LLM math. Despite the reviewer's detailed critique highlighting insufficient references, lack of exposition on usefulness, and varying levels of detail, the paper advanced to the second round. This experience led the reviewer to question the effectiveness and standards of AAAI reviewers and organizers.

This account offers a rare, first-person perspective from a reviewer, unlike typical reports that focus on author experiences or general conference statistics.